|
|
Pannier Survey - Results
Jandd - Mountain (updated 2/8/00)
Website: www.jandd.com
Click Here to rate this pannier.
Overall Results
| |
| SurveyQuestion |
Averaged Score from 7 Survey(s) |
| PurchaseDate |
|
| PurchasePrice |
$111.86 |
| MilesTraveled |
1,985.71 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
4.43   |
| Seam Strength |
4.43 |
| Stability on Rack |
3.29 |
| Mounting System Strength |
3.86 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
2.43 |
| Locking System |
3.71 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
3.57 |
| Pannier Features |
3.71 |
| Percent Recommending This Pannier? |
57 % |
| Percent Satisfied |
75% |
|
IndividualResults
| |
Submitted by Mike Ayers
Email: mrayers@inreach.com
Date Reviewed: 04/21/2000
Types of bikes you have and/or type of riding you do.
| |
trek 2120, touring, fun, commuting. |
|
| Survey Question |
Answer |
| Purchase Date |
07/01/1996 |
| Purchase Price |
$95.00 |
| Miles Traveled |
8000 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
4
|
| Seam Strength |
5 |
| Stability on Rack |
4 |
| Mounting System Strength |
4 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
1 |
| Locking System |
5 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
3 |
| Pannier Features |
4 |
| Would You Recommend This Pannier? |
Yes |
| Percent Satisfied |
75.00% |
Things To Change
OR Comments |
I had an identical pair that I used from '93-'96 until they got stolen (with my bike!). The earlier set had a better mounting system in my opinion. Jandd "improved" the bottom hook, and made them much, much harder to install/remove. I take mine off and on |
| FINAL SCORE |
3.75 |
|
|
| | |
Submitted by David Levine
Email: dl@nhrug.com
Web: www.nhrug.com
Date Reviewed: 06/25/2000
Types of bikes you have and/or type of riding you do.
| |
Solos and tandems. Road riding. Green Gear Tandem Tuesday. |
|
| Survey Question |
Answer |
| Purchase Date |
06/01/2000 |
| Purchase Price |
$100.00 |
| Miles Traveled |
50 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
5
|
| Seam Strength |
5 |
| Stability on Rack |
3 |
| Mounting System Strength |
3 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
3 |
| Locking System |
3 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
4 |
| Pannier Features |
3 |
| Would You Recommend This Pannier? |
no |
| Percent Satisfied |
50.00% |
Things To Change
OR Comments |
Too many straps. Mounting system only average and not suitable for changing from one bike to the next. Difficult to pack and load. |
| FINAL SCORE |
3.50 |
|
|
| | |
Submitted by Joe Sacher
Email: joe_sacher@yahoo.com
Date Reviewed: 07/03/2000
Types of bikes you have and/or type of riding you do.
| |
Trek 520, Vision R40 Recumbent |
|
| Survey Question |
Answer |
| Purchase Date |
05/01/1997 |
| Purchase Price |
$120.00 |
| Miles Traveled |
650 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
3
|
| Seam Strength |
4 |
| Stability on Rack |
3 |
| Mounting System Strength |
5 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
5 |
| Locking System |
5 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
2 |
| Pannier Features |
3 |
| Would You Recommend This Pannier? |
Yes |
| Percent Satisfied |
80.00% |
Things To Change
OR Comments |
The expandability is nice, but annoying for most of my rides. I tool around town and the extra straps can get in the way. It is nice to have then expandability when buying more at the grocery store than planned. :) |
| FINAL SCORE |
4.00 |
|
|
| | |
Submitted by Sean Lennon
Email: sean.lennon@fanucrobotics.com
Date Reviewed: 08/24/2000
Types of bikes you have and/or type of riding you do.
| |
Road
mountain
I primarily tour off road on my mountain bike. |
|
| Survey Question |
Answer |
| Purchase Date |
10/15/1998 |
| Purchase Price |
$159.00 |
| Miles Traveled |
4000 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
5
|
| Seam Strength |
5 |
| Stability on Rack |
3 |
| Mounting System Strength |
5 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
3 |
| Locking System |
3 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
4 |
| Pannier Features |
5 |
| Would You Recommend This Pannier? |
Yes |
| Percent Satisfied |
90.00% |
Things To Change
OR Comments |
I also own a set of mountain Large from JANDD.
I chose these panniers for their construction, which is excellent, they have gone from the continental divide trail to Tasmania with ease. the only stumbling points are the little wire hooks and backstrap that hold them on need improvement and they are a little heavy. excellent choice for durability. |
| FINAL SCORE |
4.00 |
|
|
| | |
Submitted by Scott
Date Reviewed: 10/18/2000
Types of bikes you have and/or type of riding you do.
|
| Survey Question |
Answer |
| Purchase Date |
06/01/2000 |
| Purchase Price |
$119.00 |
| Miles Traveled |
300 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
5
|
| Seam Strength |
5 |
| Stability on Rack |
3 |
| Mounting System Strength |
3 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
2 |
| Locking System |
3 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
4 |
| Pannier Features |
4 |
| Would You Recommend This Pannier? |
no |
| Percent Satisfied |
80.00% |
Things To Change
OR Comments |
The only reason I would not recommend these is because there are other panniers out there with better mounting systems. I bought Jandds for the GF and Arkels for myself, for comparison sake. Ease of mounting is night and day betwwen the two. I almost felt sorry for my girlfriend for making her deal with that lousy set-up. They were fine for on road expeditions and rail trails, but serious mountainbikers should look elsewhere (I am very happy with my Arkels for such purposes). The Jandd locking system didn't secure the bag to the rack too well, often it dangled from the rack by one hook after a drop-off or good sized bump. Part of this may be due toi the fact that it is so difficult to mount securely.
The expandibility is another issue. Since it expands upwards, it moves the center of gravity up, as well as blocks the rack from use with horizontally place items. If you want a smaller bag on the road, with the ability to occasionally expand, this is fine, otherwise, just buy a bigger and wider bag. |
| FINAL SCORE |
3.50 |
|
|
| | |
Submitted by Barry Marchessault
Email: BJMJR@Hotmail.Com
Date Reviewed: 12/27/2000
Types of bikes you have and/or type of riding you do.
| |
commute daily to work (10 miles), adventure touring mostly in asia for 1 month or more yearly |
|
| Survey Question |
Answer |
| Purchase Date |
02/05/2000 |
| Purchase Price |
$125.00 |
| Miles Traveled |
500 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
4
|
| Seam Strength |
4 |
| Stability on Rack |
3 |
| Mounting System Strength |
3 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
2 |
| Locking System |
2 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
3 |
| Pannier Features |
4 |
| Would You Recommend This Pannier? |
Yes |
| Percent Satisfied |
75.00% |
Things To Change
OR Comments |
the bottom strap for mounting was a time hard to use, howevere the ability to couple the bags together was useful |
| FINAL SCORE |
3.00 |
|
|
| | |
Submitted by John
Date Reviewed: 02/04/2007
Types of bikes you have and/or type of riding you do.
| |
68cm 1972 Windsor Light Touring
69cm 1978 Nishiki Heavy Touring
66cm 1973 Holdsworth Road
65cm 1984 Trek 400T
19" Bridgestone MB5 |
|
| Survey Question |
Answer |
| Purchase Date |
05/01/2006 |
| Purchase Price |
$65.00 |
| Miles Traveled |
400 |
| Fabric Strength / Quality |
5
|
| Seam Strength |
3 |
| Stability on Rack |
4 |
| Mounting System Strength |
4 |
| Ease of Mount / Removal from Rack |
1 |
| Locking System |
5 |
| Water / Weather Proof-ness |
5 |
| Pannier Features |
3 |
| Would You Recommend This Pannier? |
no |
| Percent Satisfied |
75.00% |
Things To Change
OR Comments |
I had to tie the bags to my racks to keep them in place. Once tied they are very stable but I can not remove them without allot of work.
Compression straps dangle and can get just possibly getin the way of the wheel. I would have cordlocks to set length and trap excess webbing when carrying small loads. There are allot of straps hanging off these bags, I am tieing them up to each other to keep them out of the wheels. With full loads this is not a problem.
The black color is a BAD CHOICE it makes it very hard to see your gear in the evening when looking for anything that is not on top.
These were a good deal on EBay and worth putting upm with the hassels given the cost and very low weight to volume ratio.
They do not leak in heavy rain, I still use plastic garbage can sacks inside. |
| FINAL SCORE |
3.57 |
|
|
|
|
|
